Friday, November 20, 2026

By Any Other Name by Jodi Picoult

 

Emilia Bassano doesn't have an easy life.  She is basically sold off at thirteen to an older man in his sixties.  Luckily, the Lord Chamberlain is not a brute but a nice man but it's always clear that Emilia must do whatever he wants and that she is there on sufferance.  Emilia is bright and helps the Lord read through the plays that he must approve before they can be staged.  She is interested in writing herself but no woman can hope to do that.  She becomes friends with Christopher Marlowe who encourages her to write and helps her find a way to get her plays staged--by paying another man, William Shakespeare, to publish them under his name.  

But Emilia falls in love with another man.  Henry is the Lord of Southampton and theirs is a true love rather than what she shares with the Lord Chamberlain.  When Emilia becomes pregnant, her life changes again.  The Lord Chamberlain is not willing to be named as the father and turns her out.  She is married off quickly to a man she doesn't know, a man who will turn out to be physically and mentally abusive.  Throughout that marriage, she continues to write plays to keep the household solvent.

Hundreds of years later, things haven't changed much in the theatre world.  Melina Green is an descendant of Emilia and she is also interested in being a playwright.  She was well on her way when a scathing critique from a male critic made her hesitant to pursue her dreams.  Finally, she writes a play that is accepted, wins a writing competition and is headed to Broadway.  But Melina is still afraid that being a woman will doom the play and gets a male friend to pretend to be her.  Can she attain her dreams?

Jodi Picoult is a well known name and usually writes about topics that cause conflict in families and in societies.  I've read lots of her novels over the years and I think this one may be her masterpiece.  I was entranced with both Emilia and Melina's stories, both of their love lives and of their ambitions.  Both women are well developed and the reader can see why they do the things they do, while cheering them on to have things turn out well.  This book is recommended for readers of women's and literary fiction.

No comments: