Coram House by Bailey Seybolt

 

Alex Kelley has come north to Lake Champlain to try to revive her career.  Her first true crime book was a bestseller as she solved a long ago cold case.  Her next occurred while her husband was battling a fatal illness and perhaps that was the reason that Alex identified the wrong perpetrator.  The young man she identified was convicted and went to prison only to be vindicated and released after time spent there.  

Now Alex has come to town to fulfill a contract by the prosecutor of a cold case.  Coram House was a Catholic orphanage, run by nuns.  But the small children there did not receive the loving care they should have.  Instead they were starved, sexually abused,  punished cruelly for the least offense and some whisper even killed.  The man who prosecuted the case has never been satisfied with the result and now wants Alex to write the story as his vindication.

The stories that haunt Alex are those of several children said to have been killed.  All center around one nun, Sister Cecile.  One girl reports that she saw the nun push a girl out of the windows she was cleaning while another reports that a young boy, Tommy, was drowned during a 'swimming lesson.' Alex is intrigued with these stories and tries to find the truth after all these years.  There are still people in town who lived at Coram House growing up, a local land developer, an alcoholic bully, a woman who lives out in the country miles from anyone and even a local detective.  None will confirm the rumors and Alex is making no progress on identifying the young boy whose story disappeared along with him.  When Alex finds an elderly woman's body in the water near a hiking trail one morning, she wonders if it is related.  As more bodies turn up, it becomes imperative for Alex to find out the long ago truth which is affecting events today.

Bailey Seybolt has worked as a writer for years, both as a travel writer and a tech writer.  Her career has been more on the nonfiction side and this is her debut novel.  Readers will relate to Alex, whose early promise faded with her big mistake in her second book and who wants to both reclaim her career and solve the mystery, giving the abused children of Coram House justice however delayed.  This book is recommended for mystery readers.