Observations By Gaslight by Lyndsay Faye

 

This is an anthology of stories that happen in the world of Sherlock Holmes.  But these are not stories told by Dr. Watson.  Instead, they are stories from the people surrounding Holmes.  Stories are told from the point of view of Irene Adler, Inspector Lestrade, one of the Baker Street Irregulars now grown and successful, another Scotland Yard detective working on his first case and Mrs. Hudson.  

We get to see Sherlock Holmes from the outside from those whose lives intersect with his but who aren't writing from the viewpoint of his best friends.  While the cases are interesting what is more interesting is seeing Holmes from these alternate views.  He is seen as a remote character but one who has a hidden reservoir of kindness and willingness to help others.  In particular, his relationship with Mrs. Hudson and with Dr. Watson seen by others is interesting.  

Lyndsay Faye is known for her work in this world.  She has written several novels that intersect with the Victorian world of Holmes and her writing is a worthy continuation of the narratives of Watson.  My favorite story was the one of the young detective asked to solve the murder of a young girl as his first case and how the various characters came together to create a successful answer to the case.  I listened to this anthology and the two narrators both did an excellent job.  This book is recommended for mystery readers and those fascinated by Sherlock Holmes.